It was a pleasure to help run the New Shul’s summer film series and thank you to everyone who came out and participated in what were three interesting and thought provoking movies.
The first of our films was Michael Moore’s new documentary “Sicko” and was followed by a lively discussion about the nature of political discourse and whether or not the “left” needs to be more or less beholden to “accuracy” than outlets like Fox News on the other end of the spectrum. However, more fundamentally, this conversation was about the real responsibility that each of us has (as Jews and as Americans) to work to repair a health care system that fails to provide affordable health care for everyone.
The second movie, was Angelina Jolie’s “A Might Heart,” which is based on Marianne Pearl’s book describing the events surrounding the kidnapping and murder of her husband, Daniel Pearl, the Jewish journalist for the Wall Street Journal. In addition to a discussion about the distracting nature of Jolie’s presence (including several long, and seemingly unnecessary, tight shots of her lips), we also discussed the role that Pearl’s Jewish identity played in the motivating the terrorists as well as a book put together by Pearl’s parents. That book – “I am Jewish” – is a compilation of essays assembled by Ruth and Judea Pearl in which Jews (some well-known) are asked to provide their explanation to Danny’s final words which were – “My father is Jewish, My mother is Jewish, I am Jewish.”
For our final movie “The Fountainhead,” we had the neat opportunity to watch Ayn Rand’s 1949 film starring Gary Cooper (Rand wrote the screenplay) outside in Battery Park at the Elevated Acre. Personally, I couldn’t help look away from the screen at times and stare at the tall buildings of the New York Skyline which play such an important role in the film itself. (which, being from NY, is something I never do!) Our discussion dealt with the nature of artistic expression and communal verses individual responsibility. And, there was a little bit of disagreement about whether or not we agreed with the final speech (see an earlier post for youtube clip) of Howard Roark (Cooper’s character) in which he outlines Rand’s philosophy.
Thank you again for this great opportunity to be a part of your community. These conversations where fun, thought provoking, and challenging in the best possible way. I look forward to many more in the upcoming year, which will include a trip to the “Hall of Origins” at the Museum of Natural History on Oct. 28th to discuss the ever-popular battle between Darwin and the Book of Genesis; a three-part series - “God’s Law: Made to be Broken?” (starting Oct. 22nd) – dealing with the interplay and/or conflict between Jewish Law and personal belief; as well our 6 @ 6 “Happy Hour” discussions and Presidential Primary Debate viewing parties. Just to name a few.
Keep checking back here as we will continue to post new and interesting thoughts and links and feel free to suggest your own!!
- Dan